There is an interesting Blog in the Guardian online titled "Behind the music: Why artists mustn't be drawn into an MP3 site's legal fight" which marries up the right of termination being actively pursued by a number of musicians and songwriters to reclaim copyrights from record labels and music publishers in the USA (the right to reclaim recordings 35 years old - notice must be filed within two years of the termination date) and the legality of so called digital cloud lockers - in particular EMI's claim against web entrepreneur Michael Robertson's MP3Tunes. Its all on the Guardian here
In 1709 (or was it 1710?) the Statute of Anne created the first purpose-built copyright law. This blog, founded just 300 short and unextended years later, is dedicated to all things copyright, warts and all.
Saturday, 3 March 2012
A Good Guardian Blog
There is an interesting Blog in the Guardian online titled "Behind the music: Why artists mustn't be drawn into an MP3 site's legal fight" which marries up the right of termination being actively pursued by a number of musicians and songwriters to reclaim copyrights from record labels and music publishers in the USA (the right to reclaim recordings 35 years old - notice must be filed within two years of the termination date) and the legality of so called digital cloud lockers - in particular EMI's claim against web entrepreneur Michael Robertson's MP3Tunes. Its all on the Guardian here
PRS win big, even if for little money
News reaches us of a decision by Mr Kevin Prosser QC sitting as a Deputy Judge of the Chancery Division on the case of PRS Ltd v Alexander Burns and Williams Burn [2012] EWHC 221 (Ch) in an action against father and son defendants to restrain them from infringing PRS’s copyright in musical works by performing music in public and damages. It’s an interesting read and Prosser QC is somewhat critical of the role of Alexander Burns, the father, an acting solicitor in the running of the Remix Bar in Woking; the Judge was less than impressed with Mr Burns as a witness and went further saying “I wish to make a further, important, comment about Mr Burns. He had a very lax attitude towards the legal obligations which he and William owed to PRS”. Burn’s DJ son William’s activities were not without criticism with the judge saying “I was not impressed by his recollection of events. He was not at all concerned about performing music at Remix Bar in public without a licence from PRS (although I accept that he was relying on his father to advise him on this) and he failed to make or keep a proper written record of usage”. But in particular its a very interesting use of Section 97 of the Copyright Designs & Patents Act 1988 in awarding damages.The actual sums of money involved are quite small and having found "flagrant infringement" Prosser QC used PRS's figures (in default of any figures from the defendants) to assess damages saying he “would encourage the parties to adopt a broad brush approach on this issue, in order to avoid further costs being incurred. On that basis, I consider that, leaving aside additional damages, they should agree that the balance of unpaid royalties amounts to £2,000, and that damages are payable amounting to £3,000, making £5,000 in total, plus interest” .
Prosser QC then went to assess "such additional damages as the justice of the case may require" pursuant to Section 97 of the CDPA 1988 saying “In my view, Mr Burns is guilty of flagrant infringement; he believed that the 2006 licence had been terminated but he did nothing to stop PRS’ copyright being infringed. Moreover, as an experienced solicitor, his lax and uncooperative attitude as mentioned [at paragraph 18] above was totally unacceptable, and it has put PRS to a great deal of time and trouble as well as expense. For these reasons I consider that the justice of the case requires that he should pay additional damages. If my broad brush approach, mentioned above, is followed by the parties, then I consider that they should agree to additional damages of three times the standard damages, that is £9,000. However, I do not consider that the justice of the case requires the court to award additional damages against William, because I consider that he was understandably relying on his father”.
No injunction was granted as the lease on the Remix Bar had been surrendered by the Burns.
The case isn't on BAILII as yet, but Lexisweb have the case report here
Labels:
CDPA S97,
copyright infringement,
damages,
prs licensing
Friday, 2 March 2012
Lessig and Doctorow head up ORGCon 2012
ORGCon is back On Saturday 24th March 2012, at the University of Westminster in the heart of London, from 9.30am onwards. And it's "packed with exciting speakers, challenging debates, and workshops that will leave your mind exploding with ideas!" There certainly is a stellar line and the its "your chance catch up with everything digital rights related, while meeting the brilliant minds of Lawrence Lessig, Cory Doctorow, Wendy Seltzer, Ross Anderson, Tom Lowenthal, and many more. From the government snooping on your data to default internet blocking and monitoring to the corporate capture of state and democratic institutions - we'll be covering vast regions of the digital rights sphere. And there may even be a competition or two!" and Joe Killock kindly tells us here at the 1709 Blog that "Lots of the programme will be about copyright of course!" Thanks Joe!
Find out more and book your ticket at http://www.openrightsgroup.org/orgcon-2012
Bull baiting in Spain
In an attempt to sabotage the new ‘Sinde' anti-piracy law that is scheduled to go into effect in Spain at the beginning of March, TorrentFreak reports that hundreds of Spanish websites are participating in a unique protest organized by a local hacktivist group. The websites are all linking to an “infringing” song - a copyrighted track from the artist Eme Navarro, who’s a member of the music rights group SGAE, but critical of the Sinde law - to the protest, who will then report the sites to the authorities to overload them with requests. It seems that while Navarro generally publishes his music under a Creative Commons license, he created an “all rights reserved” track specifically for the protest. Thanks to the hacktivist campaign hundreds of websites are now linking to this copyrighted song without permission, and Navarro reported a first batch of sites to the Ministry of Culture early on the 1st March. The theory is that as a result, the commission tasked with reviewing all the requests will be overloaded with complaints. All the reported sites have to be processed on order of arrival, so the protest will significantly slow down this review process.http://torrentfreak.com/arists-and-hacktivists-sabotage-spanish-anti-piracy-law-120301/
Thursday, 1 March 2012
Stiletto wars at Milan Fashion Week
![]() |
| Cavalli a/w 2010-11 |
To add some spice to Milan's fashion extravaganza, Florence-based Roberto Cavalli claimed that the new collection of Gucci's Frida Giannini - which privileged dark colours and gothic but (ça va sans dire) sexy shapes - was a slavish imitation of his a/w 2010-11 collection.
![]() |
| Gucci a/w 2012-13 |
So far, Gucci has refused to comment on Cavalli's allegations.
As is well known, IP protection for fashion is still a patchwork of different rights and remedies, ranging from trademarks to design rights and unfair competition or passing off. While copyright protection has often been pretty unfit to serve fashion (not to say controversial, due also to difficulties in dealing with the idea/expression dichotomy consistently), might things now perhaps get a bit clearer, following the CJEU's efforts to clarify concepts such as 'originality' and 'work'?
Something to read? Recent publications of interest
The US-based Copyright Clearance Center’s newest “Beyond the Book” podcast, featuring Newsday columnist and Fox News Channel political analyst Ellis Henican, is now out. Ahead of CCC’s bi-annual OnCopyright event Henican -- who is hosting the event -- discusses the convergence of technology and creativity, explaining how the collision of these two core values radically affects both the economy and creative world – using the term “creative economy” to define the issue at hand. Here are the podcast and the transcript.
The European Audiovisual Observatory (part of the Council of Europe in Strasbourg) has just published a new report on Internet Piracy in Europe -- particularly Russia. It's called Answers to Internet Piracy and you can buy it for a modest number of euros, in paper format or online, from the Observatory's website here (unless, presumably, you are Russian, in which case there's a good chance that you'll be getting it for free ...). According to the web-blurb:
New Challenges of Chinese Copyright Law in the Digital Age, by Seagull Haiyan Song, is a slender book of just 87 pages of text. From the subtitle "A Comparative Copyright Analysis of ISP Liability, Fair Use and Sports Telecasts" it is immediately apparent that the content is very much narrower and sharply focused than the potential width of the title suggests. The investigation by the author -- who is herself a practising IP attorney with teaching positions with two Beijing universities --can be summarised by the three questions that meet visitors to the book's web page: "Under what circumstances should [ISPs] be held liable when copyrighted material is made available over the Internet without authorization of rights holders? Is Google’s controversial Library Project to scan millions of books into digital format an ambitious plan for public good or is it just another format of copyright infringement under the digital age? When audience enjoys watching live broadcasts of sports events, who are the rights holders behind the scene, and how do they protect their rights and interests from being infringed?"
What of the comparative element? The publisher, Wolters Kluwer, explains:
Bibliographic data: ISBN: 9789041137937. Hardcover: xii + 87 pages. Price $80.00. Web page here
********************************
The European Audiovisual Observatory (part of the Council of Europe in Strasbourg) has just published a new report on Internet Piracy in Europe -- particularly Russia. It's called Answers to Internet Piracy and you can buy it for a modest number of euros, in paper format or online, from the Observatory's website here (unless, presumably, you are Russian, in which case there's a good chance that you'll be getting it for free ...). According to the web-blurb:
"The fierce protest sparked in many European countries in February 2012 by the signing of the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA) is a perfect illustration of the balancing act that legislators have to perform when enshrining the protection of intellectual property rights in law. The interests of both users and rightholders require a compromise that is felt to be “fair”.
The lead article, of which which you can get some flavour from the marketing page here, makes riveting reading -- so if you want to be riveted, you know where to go!Although the question of shaping the details of copyrights is the focus of intense debate, there is a relatively broad consensus that piracy, that is to say the systematic violation of these rights, must be combated. This IRIS plus [it's not immediately apparent here, but IRIS appears to be a trade mark for the Legal Observations of the European Audiovisual Observatory] looks at the issue of combating internet piracy, which has become an explosive subject, especially owing to the constant improvements in the efficiency of electronic data exchange and the consequent rise in copyright violations".
**********************************
New Challenges of Chinese Copyright Law in the Digital Age, by Seagull Haiyan Song, is a slender book of just 87 pages of text. From the subtitle "A Comparative Copyright Analysis of ISP Liability, Fair Use and Sports Telecasts" it is immediately apparent that the content is very much narrower and sharply focused than the potential width of the title suggests. The investigation by the author -- who is herself a practising IP attorney with teaching positions with two Beijing universities --can be summarised by the three questions that meet visitors to the book's web page: "Under what circumstances should [ISPs] be held liable when copyrighted material is made available over the Internet without authorization of rights holders? Is Google’s controversial Library Project to scan millions of books into digital format an ambitious plan for public good or is it just another format of copyright infringement under the digital age? When audience enjoys watching live broadcasts of sports events, who are the rights holders behind the scene, and how do they protect their rights and interests from being infringed?"
What of the comparative element? The publisher, Wolters Kluwer, explains:
"All these questions have become highly important under the digital age, and therefore drawn serious attention from legal scholars and legislators worldwide. For direction, the world looks to influential legal regimes arising from the U.S. copyright law, the EU Directives, along with the jurisprudence and legal theory that attaches to each. But the world also looks to China, where a rapidly evolving legal regime holds its own course. This very useful book compares the legislation and case law of Chinese copyright law with those of the United States and European countries, focusing on three subjects - the liability of Internet Service Providers, the ‘fair use’ versus ‘fair dealing’ copyright doctrine, and the copyrightability of live sports telecasts - all of which are unsettled questions of law under the existing copyright regime".Considering how thin the book is, it contains a great deal of information, and indeed careful thought -- as befits a text which has evolved from a UC Berkeley School of Law JSD thesis. The subject is one which will continue to develop and subsequent revisions of this volume can be expected to thicken out in very little time.
Bibliographic data: ISBN: 9789041137937. Hardcover: xii + 87 pages. Price $80.00. Web page here
Football Dataco ruling: if no creative freedom, no copyright -- despite the skill and effort
![]() |
| It's not enough to keep possession of the ball: you have to be creative too ... |
"A football fixture list cannot be protected by copyright when its compilation is dictated by rules or constraints which leave no room for creative freedom
The fact that the compilation of the list required significant labour and skill on the part of its creator does not justify, in itself, it being protected by copyright
The Database Directive [Directive 96/9/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 March 1996 on the legal protection of databases] grants copyright protection to databases if the selection or arrangement of their contents constitute the author’s own intellectual creation. The databases can also be eligible for protection by a so-called ‘sui generis’ right when the obtention, verification or presentation of their contents required a substantial investment.
In the main proceedings, the UK company Football Dataco, which is responsible for protecting the rights acquired in the English and Scottish football league fixtures, and the organisers of those leagues accuse Yahoo! UK, Stan James (a bookmaker) and Enetpulse (a sports information provider) of having infringed their intellectual property rights in the football fixture lists by having used those fixture lists without paying financial compensation.
The fixture lists are prepared in accordance with several ‘golden rules’. The process of preparing is in part automated but requires, however, very significant labour and skill in order to satisfy the multitude of requirements of the parties concerned whilst respecting the rules. The national court has already rejected a ‘sui generis’ protection of those fixture lists in accordance with the case-law of the Court of Justice [Joined Cases C-46/02, C-338/02 and C-444/02] Fixtures Marketing]. By contrast, it raises the question of the possibility of those lists being eligible for copyright protection. In that context, it asks the Court of Justice to clarify the conditions which must be satisfied in order to be eligible for that protection.
The Court states, first, that the copyright protection provided for by the Database Directive concerns the ‘structure’ of the database, and not its ‘contents’. That protection does not extend to the data itself. In that context, the concepts of ‘selection’ and of ‘arrangement’ within the meaning of the directive refer respectively to the selection and the arrangement of data, through which the author gives the database its structure. By contrast, those concepts do not extend to the creation of the data contained in that database. Consequently, the intellectual effort and skill of creating data are not relevant in order to assess the eligibility of the database that contains them for the copyright protection provided for by the directive.
In the present case, the effort and skill of creating the lists relate to the creation of the same data contained in the base. As a consequence, that effort and skill are, in any event, of no relevance in order to assess the eligibility of the football fixture lists concerned for the copyright protection provided for by the directive.
The Court then observes that the notion of ‘intellectual creation’, which is a necessary condition in order to be eligible for copyright protection, refers to the sole criterion of originality. As regards the setting up of a database, that criterion of originality is satisfied when, through the selection or arrangement of the data which it contains, its author expresses his creative ability in an original manner by making free and creative choices. By contrast, that criterion is not satisfied when the setting up of the database is dictated by technical considerations, rules or constraints which leave no room for creative freedom.
The ‘addition of important significance’ to the data by their selection or arrangement in the
database does not affect the determination of the originality required for that database to be protected by copyright.
Similarly, the fact that the setting up of the database required, irrespective of the creation of the data which it contains, significant labour and skill on the part of its author does not justify, as such, the protection of it by copyright if that labour and that skill do not express any originality in the selection or arrangement of that data.
It is for the national court to assess, in the light of the considerations set out by the Court, whether the football fixture lists concerned are databases which satisfy the conditions of eligibility for copyright protection. However, the Court adds that unless the procedures for creating the lists concerned as described by the national court are supplemented by elements reflecting originality in the selection or arrangement of the data contained in those lists, they do not suffice for those lists to be protected by the copyright laid down in the directive.
Finally, the Court states that, given that the directive harmonises the protection given by copyright to databases, national legislation which grants copyright protection under conditions which are different to those set out in the directive is incompatible with European Union law".This is much along the lines of what this blogger was expecting. However he notes with interest the comment that
"unless the procedures for creating the lists concerned as described by the national court are supplemented by elements reflecting originality in the selection or arrangement of the data contained in those lists, they do not suffice for those lists to be protected by the copyright laid down in the directive".This reflects para [44] of the Court's ruling. While it's not a positive finding of fact -- something which is left for the national courts -- it has a sort of negative fact-finding effect in that the Court of Justice is circumscribing the manner in which the national court can evaluate and apply the facts before it to the law.
Merlin settles for the indies
The global independent music rights agency Merlin has settled its long-running copyright infringement claim on behalf of its members against the now defunct peer-to-peer service LimeWire. The settlement was reached out-of-court subsequent to a lawsuit filed by Merlin in July 2011. Merlin’s settlement follows the major record labels’ announcement that they reached a $105 million out-of-court settlement with LimeWire in May 2011.Merlin’s members’ claims against LimeWire were settled for an amount commensurate with the major record labels’ settlement, taking into account the aggregate market shares of the Merlin members relative to the major labels’ shares and costs of action. Merlin’s members’ market share in the US is around 10%. Merlin will pay out the proceeds of the settlement to its members shortly. Labels such as Epitaph, Merge, Warp, Yep Roc/Red Eye, Naïve, Naxos, Tommy Boy, One Little Indian, Kontor, Secretly Canadian, Beggars Group, [PIAS] Group,!K7, Sub Pop, Domino and Koch/E1 are all members of Merlin. Charles Caldas, Merlin CEO said:
“It is deeply satisfying to announce this settlement today. The exclusion of independents from past major settlements such as Kazaa was a key factor in the formation of Merlin, and I am proud to say that this time, via the actions of Merlin, our members’ rights have been properly protected. We will continue to do everything we can to ensure that the labels we represent are never again left out in the cold”.http://www.merlinnetwork.org/home/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






