1709 Blog: for all the copyright community

Monday, 28 September 2015

Recent French Ruling on the Protection of Slogans





                                                                       





The issue of the protection of slogans (or taglines) as intellectual property is always of interest inasmuch as it is often perceived as existing at the crossroads of copyright and trademark law.

As we know, copyright protection raises thorny issues of originality (in short expressions) and trademark registration for such expressions is often complicated by their inherently promotional and laudatory nature.

However, a recent (June 9, 2015) ruling by the French Cour de cassation reminds us that general tort law should not be ignored in such cases and, in particular, in French law what is called parasitisme or parasitical conduct.

Cora, a retailer that had been using the advertising slogan “large volumes = low prices” (gros volumes = petits prix) for 25 years, took legal action against Auchan for committing what it felt were acts of parasitical conduct by distributing catalogues featuring the slogans ‘mini prices for large volumes’ (prix mini sur gros volumes), ‘large volumes at mini prices’ (gros volumes à prix mini) and ‘large volumes big savings’ (gros volumes grosses économies).

The Cour de cassation upheld the factual analysis of the lower court, which had held in favour of the plaintiff and stated that “Parasitism, for commercial traders, exists where one entity rides on the coattails of another by unduly benefiting from its repute or investments, irrespective of any risk of confusion”. 

Following a syntactical, phonetic and visual analysis of the slogans at issue, the court found that the combination of two groups of three-syllable words ‘gros volumes’ and ‘petit prix’ placed on equal footing is not a part of common everyday language. It also found that the association of the two phrases to be original  and distinctive of Cora. Auchan used identical syntactical structure in forming its slogans, merely replacing the sign ‘=’ in Cora’s slogan with a coma, where the use of words ‘prix mini sur gros volumes’ and ‘gros volumes à prix mini’ had a resonance that was parallel to that of Cora's. Moreover, Auchan’s use of slogans, even after repeated warnings given by Cora, did not seem to be mere coincidence as there were numerous other ways to express the same idea. Finally, the court noted that Cora had carried out multiple advertising campaigns that contributed to its reputation.

Link to ruling here


No comments: